Lyme disease causing Borrelia are genetically distinct from their relapsing fever causing cousins
Lyme disease, a tick-borne infection caused by the bacterium Borrelia burgdorferi and its relatives, is currently the most prevalent vector-borne disease in North America and temperate regions of Eurasia. Increasing temperatures have expanded the habitat range for the tick vectors of Lyme disease and estimates now suggest that over 300,000 people in North America are afflicted by the disease annually, making Lyme disease a growing public health concern. Members of the genus Borrelia are also the causative agents of relapsing fever, another vector-borne infection which is characterized by recurring episodes of fever, headache, aches, and nausea. Currently, the members of the genus Borrelia are separated into two main groups based upon their pathogenicity profiles, the Lyme disease Borrelia and the relapsing fever Borrelia. The two groups are difficult to distinguish morphologically and are primarily distinguished from each other based on the arthropod vectors which transmit them, their pathogenicity, and by a limited number of biochemical and genetic tests in clinical environments. Previous research into the evolutionary relationships among the Borrelia species suggests that the Lyme disease Borrelia and the relapsing fever Borrelia form two distinct groups within the genus. However, due to a lack of reliable molecular, morphological, or biochemical characteristics that can distinguish these groups, the two groups of Borrelia were not separated into distinct genera.
In this study, we have compared the genomic sequences of 38 genomes from 18 species of Borrelia to identify genetic traits, which can distinguish the Lyme disease Borrelia from the relapsing fever Borrelia. The two types of differentiating traits we have focussed on are known as conserved signature insertions/deletions (CSIs), which are insertions or deletions only present in the protein sequences of a related group of organisms (Fig. 1), and conserved signature proteins (CSPs), which are proteins found only in a related group of organisms.
Our work has identified many unique genetic traits (53 CSIs and 25 CSPs) which clearly distinguish the Lyme disease Borrelia and the relapsing fever Borrelia from each other (Fig. 2). The distinctness of these two groups of Borrelia species was also supported by the results of an average nucleotide identity analysis of Borrelia genomes and by phylogenetic trees constructed based upon the 16S rRNA gene and protein sequences.
The results reported in our work, from multiple lines of investigations, provides compelling evidence that the Borrelia species are comprised of at least two distinct groups of organisms corresponding to the Lyme disease Borrelia and the relapsing fever Borrelia. Of the two groups, we would have liked to retain the genus name Borrelia for the Lyme disease Borrelia, which includes the best known species from this genus, B. burgdorferi. However, the type species of the genus Borrelia, B. anserina, is a part of the relapsing fever group. Hence, according to the rules governing the description of new bacterial names, the genus name Borrelia must be retained by the relapsing fever group. To minimize confusion among scientists and other health care professionals, we proposed that the species that are part of the Lyme disease Borrelia should be transferred to a new genus, Borreliella. The name Borreliella retains much of the original name of the genus Borrelia, thus, it is unlikely that the species with the new names (e.g. Borreliella burgdorferi and B. burgdorferi) could be confused with any other unrelated species and the name should be instantly recognizable by researchers or clinicians working on Lyme disease.
In addition to distinguishing the two main groups of Borrelia species, the unique genetic traits identified here should lead to improved understanding of the two groups of Borrelia species and of their associated diseases. The genetic traits identified in the present work provide scientists, for the first time, novel means to rapidly and unambiguously distinguish between the two main groups of Borrelia species via PCR-based or immunological diagnostic assays. More importantly, the unique genetic characteristics for the two groups of Borrelia species identified here provide important targets for functional studies and their results should lead to novel biochemical and pathological insights into the aspects of these microbes that are responsible for causation of Lyme disease and relapsing fever.
Mobolaji Adeolu and Radhey S. Gupta
Department of Biochemistry and Biomedical Sciences,
McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
A phylogenomic and molecular marker based proposal for the division of the genus Borrelia into two genera: the emended genus Borrelia containing only the members of the relapsing fever Borrelia, and the genus Borreliella gen. nov. containing the members of the Lyme disease Borrelia (Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato complex).
Adeolu M, Gupta RS
Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek. 2014 Jun