Physics of the mechanical toy Gee-Haw Whammy Diddle

Gee-haw whammy diddle is a mechanical toy consisting of two wooden rods and a propeller. The main rod has a series of notches engraved in it and a propeller loosely attached to its end. The driving rod is used for rubbing over the notches of the main rod, causing the propeller to rotate. Skilled performers can achieve high rotation speeds of the propeller and quickly change the direction of rotation.

The propeller’s rotation can be explained using a combination of two different mechanisms. Firstly, as the driving rod is rubbed over the notches of the main rod, the main rod starts to vibrate; the properties of these vibrations are determined by the grip used and the force exerted by the performer. Secondly, as the main rod is vibrating, the propeller starts to collide with the nail, resulting in its rotation.

A typical gee-haw whammy diddle.

Fig. 1. A typical gee-haw whammy diddle.

It has previously been assumed that for the propeller to rotate, it needs to stay in continuous contact with the nail and synchronize with its motion, similar to a person driving a hula hoop using their hips. Under this view of the nail-propeller system, it had also been assumed that an elliptic motion of the nail is necessary for rotation of the propeller.

Using a mechanical vibrator to control the motion of the main rod and a high-speed, high-resolution camera, we have investigated a broad range of novel conditions, leading to a new conceptual understanding of the gee-haw whammy diddle. The following observations act as a simple summary of our findings.

Observation 1
Elliptical movement of the nail is not necessary for starting and maintaining the rotation of the propeller. A perfectly symmetric linear motion of the nail may induce rotation of the propeller in a random direction.

Observation 2
The propeller is only able to rotate if it separates from the nail during its movement. For the propeller to separate, the nail needs to accelerate downwards faster than the gravitational acceleration. If the nail accelerates significantly faster than this critical value, the additional acceleration is only detrimental, and the propeller’s speed decreases.

Observation 3
A spinning propeller spends most of its time in free fall, only interrupted by frequent but extremely short collisions with the nail. These collisions cumulatively contribute to the propeller’s overall rotation, as displayed in Figure 2.

Physics of the mechanical toy Gee-Haw Whammy Diddle

Fig. 2. Estimated propeller speed based on its collisions with the nail (blue) vs the propeller’s actual speed (red) during the first few seconds of its movement.

As a whole, these observations contribute to a new conceptual model of the gee-haw whammy diddle. Rather than seeing it as a simple continuous mechanism (like the hula-hoop), the gee-haw whammy diddle is a fundamentally chaotic system of random collisions leading to a stable motion of the propeller under the right conditions – namely an optimal acceleration of the nail and sufficiently high friction between the nail and the propeller.

Martin Marek 1, Matej Badin 2, Martin Plesch 3,4
1Joint School Novohradská, GJH, Bratislava, Slovakia
2Comenius University, Faculty of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics, Bratislava, Slovakia
3Slovak Academy of Sciences, Institute of Physics, Bratislava, Slovakia
4Masaryk University, Institute of Computer Science, Brno, Czech Republic

Publication

Physics of the mechanical toy Gee-Haw Whammy Diddle.
Marek M, Badin M, Plesch M
Sci Rep. 2018 Feb 27

Facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedinmailFacebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedinmail

Leave a Reply